We suspected something didn't sound completely harmonious between The Hart & Hunter chefs and those taking over Lilly's under the name Wolf in Sheep's Clothing. After all, Kris Tominaga and Brian Dusnmoor just opened a new restaurant, why would they want to water it down so quickly with dual restaurants serving the same menu? Eater proves our skepticism correct, getting word from Tominaga that the the new restaurant might be masquerading as the same place that he launched last year with Dunsmoor and owner John Mascarenhas. Today Tominaga tells the blog, "The new wisc restaurant...has no connection with us. We're pretty outraged and feel taken advantage of. Brian myself and none of the wolf in sheeps clothing staff are involved with that project...and this is more or less a knock off of our hard work and ideas."
As the chief proprietor, Mascarenhas obviously owns the name and intellectual property rights to "Wolf in Sheep's Clothing," and is free to do what he likes with the title on the legal side of the fight. And arguing that it did indeed open as "Wolf in Sheep's Clothing" or that Mascarenhas "took" the name is false, contrary to Eater's report. As always, Yo! Venice! reported this news correctly and objectively.
But as Tominaga and Dunsmoor built the concept while it was a temporary restaurant, this feels not only a little unfair to the two talented chefs who turned the brand into a success, it's also conceivably taking advantage of the public who loved the pop-up under this same name and will flock to what they think is Wolf in Sheep's Clothing expecting a similar experience. The lack of any announcement running up to the restaurant only makes us think someone may have tried to pull the wool over Abbot Kinney's eyes.
This summer, we had a fairly unspectacular dinner of great product in overly fussy dishes, dry salmon, and bland pork cheek at the Kathman-helmed AK Supper Club. A paying friend sitting with a visiting chef and her party at a nearby table had even less enthusiasm for their dinner then we did. All of which is to warn you, a Wolf by the same name with any other chef may not always taste as sweet.